My sister-in-law the psychologist once observed, not unkindly, that I had a restrained eating disorder. I was grateful she called it “restrained.” I was raised by a mother who joked it would be OK to be anorexic for a week and a grandmother who was always trying to lose five pounds, despite a pocketbook filled with coffee candies and a Brooklyn kitchen stocked with Waldbaum’s chocolate chip cookies.
In our family, weight loss was cause for celebration, not fear. My mother and grandmother loved clothes and excelled at sewing and altering them. A cold, gray Saturday afternoon often yielded a trip to Loehmann’s, where we stripped down to our underwear in a communal dressing room and tried on designer clothes that had been dramatically marked down. There was no question that clothes looked better on bodies that were smaller. I was the first grandchild and only granddaughter; what I looked like mattered, and there was only one way to look: thin.
There was no arguing this point. Better to close my mouth (literally and figuratively) and hew to the strict party line: Diet or die trying.
Away at a New England women’s college, I ate donuts for breakfast, cracked my teeth on sucking candies, chain-smoked Marlboro Lights, guzzled coffee and Tab, popped NoDoz and wrote for the college newspaper.
My weight yo-yoed — up, down, all around. By the end of freshman year, I was pushing 140 pounds. Eventually, I started to run and kept smoking; eventually, I stopped smoking and kept running. Running stabilized my weight to the point where I no longer had to think about it too much. I graduated college weighing 116.
After college, I worked for an investment bank, then for Bloomberg Business Week. The female gaze was replaced by the male one. I was judged for my work and for my appearance. Fortunately this was before social media, and though I sometimes appeared on TV to promote a story, my weight didn’t matter as much as my words did.
Still, I cared. Before my wedding, I lost seven pounds; when I became pregnant with my first son, I gained 35. After my father attempted suicide, I lost it all and more. It was thrilling to get married and have a baby; it was devastating to watch my father try to end his life. By the time I had my second son, I knew that my weight didn’t reflect anything particularly right or wrong with my life.
And yet, I weighed myself every day on a scale ludicrously called “Thinner.” In high school, I had sneaky ways of shedding weight: Shave my underarms and legs, sweat in the sauna at our tennis club, then step on the scale. Later, deep into motherhood, I weighed myself after I’d exercised and before showering (wet hair adds weight). The scale had me in its grip. Did knowing my weight make me happy or sad? Sad.